Speed Gibson

of the International Secret Police

Wrapping Up the 281 Vision

The Robbinsdale Area Schools, District 281, has been doing a fast-paced visioning process the past month. This was deemed necessary before the referendum last year, and especially after it was defeated. I have posted my support for this process and participated in six of the many community visioning sessions: two general, one each high school, middle school, elementary, and ECFE.

Today, Saturday, was the big wrap up meeting where all that raw input and preliminary scoring was presented to a group of 32 "community leaders" drawn from the School Board, District Staff (principals and below), city government, business, parents, and taxpayers. I was honored to be invited by the Board as one of those 32 evaluators.

This went from about 8:30 am to nearly 3 pm, with only a quick lunch for a break. A number of initiatives for change were developed, including action plans. Much as I would like to share those outcomes, the Board and Staff will now work this up into a formal document to be presented at the Monday, May 5 School Board meeting. I'm going to be respectful and let the Board present it at the Monday, May 5 regular session at 7 pm. I will be out of town that day, but will have the DVR record it via Comcast channel 22.

I will share this: Superintendent Stan Mack made an interesting observation at the end, expressing some surprise that class sizes didn't make the final cut. It appeared throughout the raw data, but apparently the other issues around it always seemed more important to us. I agree with Mack, this is surprising indeed, having heard this over and over at the community visioning sessions I attended.

But now that I think about it, this could be evidence of a successful process today. For while both staff and parents cite class size as a concern, when listed with other issues it took its rightful status as a symptom. Address the other issues like funding, scheduling, and testing, and class sizes will take care of themselves.

I found this whole process very helpful to me, gaining considerable understanding of how the district works and what the parents expect. But now it's time to resume my quest for understandable financials, possibly as part of one or more initiatives developed today.
The Reticulator (mail) (www):
Having participated in sessions of that sort myself, in local school districts and in other organizations, I'm pretty skeptical of that method of developing initiatives. Sometimes a few good things can come of them when individuals come well prepared in advance. But really good planning of this kind either needs to be the vision of an exceptionally talented individual (and s/he will make some big mistakes, too) or it needs to be an extremely iterative process, with lots of time in between to step back and think about what has been said and done. And it needs to represent a lot of points of view that will never get invited to the table by a central administration, and which will never get considered unless it is an adversarial process.

BTW, do you have a new official start date for summer to begin? :-) My parents are snowed in at Park Rapids.
4.27.2008 1:14pm
J. Ewing (mail):
All of that, and nobody even hinted at the "class size myth"? I'm glad to hear that other things are more important, but funding shouldn't be one of them. Things like teacher competence, a solid curriculum, good discipline, high expectations and even teacher salaries are far more important. In fact, above the third grade and so long as the physical constraints of the classroom aren't exceeded, there are no studies showing that class size matters.

In simple terms, we keep pouring more money into education, hiring more teachers and reducing class sizes, but without results. Change the environment and you could educate for half what we're spending now.
4.27.2008 2:19pm
R-Five (Speed Gibson) (www):
We have to decode the spending to have a meaningful class size discussion. If it turns out that the teacher is only 20% of the total cost, and the square feet is 10%, maybe I should study the other 70% first.

As for my idea of summer, I'm about ready to rescind spring!
4.27.2008 3:16pm

Post as: [Register] [Log In]

Account:
Password:
Remember info?